US banks are backing away from crypto companies, concerned by a regulatory crackdown that threatens to sever digital currencies from the real-world financial system. Banking regulators are raising concerns about banks’ involvement with crypto clients following last year’s blowup of Sam Bankman-Fried’s FTX. The Securities and Exchange Commission is aggressively pursuing the industry’s bigger players in a crackdown that threatens to narrow their reach. That move has alarmed bankers who don’t want to do business with customers in the SEC’s crosshairs, people familiar with the matter said.[1]
According to people familiar with the industry, bankers are now re-evaluating any exposure to the crypto sector, no matter how small. The few smaller banks that got deep into crypto are reducing their exposure to the market or cutting ties altogether. Banks that kept their distance from crypto are trying even harder to stay away, closing accounts and shunning customers with potential connections to the industry.
See: https://redskyalliance.org/xindustry/what-is-the-future-of-cryptocurrency
New York’s Metropolitan Commercial Bank recently announced closing its crypto business, citing material changes in the regulatory environment. Signature Bank cut ties with the international business of Binance, the biggest crypto exchange. One of crypto’s leading banks, the lender started paring back its relationships with crypto depositors late last year.
The crackdown is squeezing crypto businesses. While the industry often pitched itself as an alternative to banks, these firms still rely heavily on banks to link up with a financial system that runs on hard currencies such as dollars and euros. Without banks, crypto companies struggle to pay their employees and enable customers to move money in and out of digital currencies.
When bitcoin first gained popularity years ago, it was difficult for crypto firms to open bank accounts. A handful of smaller lenders, struggling to compete with big banks for deposit dollars, opened their doors, often banking only the bigger crypto players they thought were safest. These banks don’t hold digital currencies. Instead, they provide corporate accounts for crypto companies. Some, such as Silvergate Capital Corp., also built special networks to enable transfers between big investors and crypto exchanges.
For a time, banking regulators warmed to crypto activities. In 2020, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency said it would allow banks to hold cryptocurrencies for customers. Regulators reversed course following the FTX meltdown. In January, the three major banking regulators warned banks that they were concerned about their crypto ties. The regulators said they had “significant safety and soundness concerns” and questioned if the industry could be safely banked.
See: https://redskyalliance.org/xindustry/sec-chairman-pushes-for-more-cryptocurrency-regulations
“That was a red flare that basically says, ‘Banks, if you’re going to be anywhere near the crypto business, we’re going to be looking at you very carefully,’” said Thomas Vartanian, executive director of the Financial Technology and Cybersecurity Center. “At the end of the day, banks will have to ask themselves if it’s worth the aggravation.”
Regulators generally do not tell banks that they cannot do business with customers operating legitimate businesses. Instead, they categorize customers as higher risk through formal public statements reinforced by feedback from the examiners who burrow into their operations to ensure they are not taking undue risks. Banks often then decide these customers aren’t worth the regulatory headache and cut them off.
Citigroup Inc. abruptly closed Swan Bitcoin’s account in November 2022, said Cory Klippsten, chief executive of the bitcoin trading platform, forcing him to scramble to pay his 100 employees. He said that Citigroup investment bankers who had been pitching to work with him tried to intervene but were unsuccessful. Soon afterward, Mr. Klippsten said, his accounts at Citigroup were closed, too. He said he was never explained.
Matthew Homer, a former regulator now advising and investing in crypto firms, said his clients are having difficulty landing bank accounts. A First Republic representative told Mr. Homer the bank avoids crypto-related companies. Mercury, a banking service for startups, asks if a business is related to crypto in the sign-up process, Mr. Homer said. A spokesman for Mercury said it conducts more due diligence on these businesses because of regulatory uncertainty. A representative for First Republic declined to comment.
Signature is the highest-profile bank to retreat from the crypto market. In early 2022, 27% of its $109 billion deposits were from its digital-asset clients. Last year, the bank announced plans to pare back the share of deposits from the crypto business to less than 15% and to cap the number of deposits from any individual crypto customer. Regulators didn’t tell them to back away, but the bank felt they “agreed with what we were doing,” Chief Executive Joe DePaolo said. Bank officers said they don’t regret getting into crypto, even if they now spend much time reassuring their customers in other industries about their exposure. They believe the blockchain technology behind the payments network popular with crypto customers is relevant to companies such as payroll providers and cargo shippers.
Some banks, meanwhile, are sticking with crypto. Silvergate went all-in on crypto and does not have the same revenue sources as Signature. It lost the bulk of its crypto deposits in a run on the bank last quarter and is cutting jobs and shrinking its business to lower costs. Silvergate said it remains committed to serving crypto companies.
Two companies trying to win banking licenses have been left in limbo after winning preliminary approval in early 2021 from the OCC. Paxos National Trust and Protego Trust Co. applied to start banks that would hold crypto assets for clients and facilitate trading. Protego’s conditional charter expired recently. Paxos said on Twitter that it continues to “work constructively with the OCC.”
Red Sky Alliance is a Cyber Threat Analysis and Intelligence Service organization. For questions, comments, or assistance, please get in touch with the office directly at 1-844-492-7225, or feedback@wapacklabs.com
Weekly Cyber Intelligence Briefings:
- Reporting: https://www. redskyalliance. org/
- Website: https://www. wapacklabs. com/
- LinkedIn: https://www. linkedin. com/company/64265941
Weekly Cyber Intelligence Briefings:
REDSHORTS - Weekly Cyber Intelligence Briefings
https://attendee.gotowebinar.com/register/5504229295967742989
[1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/banks-are-breaking-up-with-crypto-during-regulatory-crackdown-22de1832
Comments